Visit Sbarro for New York Pizza, Pastas, & Salads. Started by the Sbarro family, we are the original XL New York pizza by the slice. Made from scratch dough made daily and stretched by hand. The sauce is the same way Mama Sbarro made it, with only the freshest, all-natural San Marzano tomatoes and a pinch of basil and our cheese is hand-shredded and made with 100% whole milk since 1956.